He was not discriminatory in his habits, purloining second-class and special-delivery items alike. His landlord told the New York Post that it had taken postal agents five hours to remove the hoard of post from the apartment.
When investigators confronted Mr Brucato, he reportedly confessed that "on some days" he failed to deliver the post on his route "for various personal reasons".
In court, his lawyer said Mr Brucato suffered from depression and alcoholism. A judge released him pending a court hearing, on condition that he "abstain from excessive alcohol consumption" in the meantime. Mr Brucato, who has been suspended by the US Postal Service without pay, could face up to five years in prison if convicted.
The Postal Service has said it will attempt to see that the 40,000 undelivered letters finally make it to their intended recipients.
Mr Brucato is not the first New York postie to be caught neglecting his duties. In March, 24-year-old Patrick Paskett, of Long Island, was arrested for throwing more than 1,000 items of post into rubbish bins along his route.
- The Independent