"Seeing the date, I realised that was likely from a home hit by a tornado. How else is it going to be there?" Posten said. "It's not a receipt. It's well-kept photo."
So, doing what any 21st-century person would do, she posted an image of the photo on Facebook and Twitter and asked for help in finding its owners. She said she was hoping someone on social media would have a connection to the photo or share it with someone who had a connection.
Sure enough, that's what happened.
"A lot of people shared it on Facebook. Someone came across it who is friends with a man with the same last name, and they tagged him," said Posten, 30, who works for a tech company.
That man was Cole Swatzell, who commented that the photo belonged to family members in Dawson Springs, Kentucky, almost 209km away from New Albany, as the crow flies, and 269km away by car.
In Dawson Springs — a town of about 2700 people 97km east of Paducah — homes were levelled, trees were splintered and search and rescue teams continued to scour the community for any survivors. Dozens of people across five states were killed.
Posten plans to return the photo to the Swatzell family sometime this week.
"It's really remarkable, definitely one of those things, given all that has happened, that makes you consider how valuable things are — memories, family heirlooms, and those kinds of things," Posten said. "It shows you the power of social media for good. It was encouraging that immediately there were tons of replies from people, looking up ancestry records, and saying 'I know someone who knows someone and I'd like to help'."
- AP