Education Minister Erica Stanford says David Seymour was “overstepping the mark somewhat” and worrying increase in hostility towards LGBTQ+ rights.
A former surgeon goes on trial this month charged with raping or sexually assaulting almost 300 former patients, most of them children and many of them unconscious at the time, over a quarter of a century across western France.
The sheer scale and horror of theallegations against Joel Le Scouarnec, 74, means his four-month trial, due to start on February 24, is likely to have an immense impact at home and abroad.
And it will have added resonance coming two months after Frenchman Dominique Pelicot was convicted of enlisting dozens of strangers to rape his heavily sedated then-wife Gisele Pelicot, a case that made her a feminist hero worldwide.
In this case, Le Scouarnec is the sole defendant accused of crimes against hundreds of victims.
The trial, in the city of Vannes in Brittany, will be held in public but seven days of testimony from victims who were targeted while minors will be behind closed doors.
“Mr Le Scouarnec has generally acknowledged his involvement in many of the events in question” as well as his “concealment strategies”, said regional prosecutor Stephane Kellenberger.
The average age of the victims is 11 but the former surgeon is also accused of raping a 1-year-old and sexually assaulting a 70-year-old.
Recluse with dolls
He allegedly committed the sexual violence between 1989 and 2014 when he worked at a dozen medical institutions in western France.
Le Scouarnec is being tried for 111 rapes and 189 sexual assaults, aggravated by the fact that he abused his position as a doctor and mostly targeted children.
In total, 256 victims out of the 299 were younger than 15.
A court sketch of French retired surgeon Joel Le Scouarnec. Photo / AFP
If convicted, Le Scouarnec faces a maximum sentence of 20 years in prison – French law does not allow sentences to be added together even when there are multiple victims.
The former doctor is already in prison after being sentenced in December 2020 to 15 years for raping and sexually assaulting four children, including two of his nieces.
Many victims were traumatised when they learned of the events, sometimes decades later. Not all of them will take part in the trial but many say they expect the proceedings to provide explanations.
The authorities began investigating Le Scouarnec in 2017 after a 6-year-old girl who lived in the same neighbourhood in the southwestern town of Jonzac alleged he had raped her.
The initial inquiry uncovered the assaults on his nieces and a 4-year-old patient all committed in the 1990s and he was handed 15 years in prison for these crimes in December 2020.
When investigators searched Le Scouarnec’s house in Jonzac, where he lived as a recluse, they found dozens of dolls that he used as sex toys along with 300,000 pornographic images.
In another parallel with the trial of Dominique Pelicot – who filmed the male visitors to the family home – Le Scouarnec carefully wrote down the names of his victims, some of whom he abused on the operating table.
‘Possessed by the devil’
While Le Scouarnec is the sole defendant, the actions of officials will come under scrutiny at the trial.
It was only after the 2017 complaint and his being remanded in custody that Le Scouarnec was struck off the medical register.
He had been convicted at the end of 2005 for downloading child sexual abuse images. But the four-month suspended sentence he received was not accompanied by any obligation to receive treatment or a ban on practising.
Le Scouarnec then found work at a hospital in the Brittany town of Quimperle and even got promoted despite the management being made aware of his conviction.
He then moved to southwestern France, where he worked until his retirement in 2017.
A separate investigation has been opened by regional prosecutors for “failure to prevent a crime or offence against the integrity of persons”, though it is not yet targeting any individual or institution.
Children’s rights association La Voix de l’Enfant (The Child’s Voice), a civil party in the trial, filed a complaint in April 2023 against the judicial authorities and the ministry of health for “endangering the lives of others”.
Le Scouarnec’s lawyer, Thibaut Kurzawa, told AFP that “his state of mind has not changed”.
“He wants to defend himself and he wants to explain himself,” he said.
He was married and had three sons born, between 1980 and 1987. The couple separated in the early 2000s, but their divorce was not made official until 2023.
His wife, interviewed in 2019 in the regional Le Telegramme newspaper, insisted she “never” had any suspicions, even if she had caught him “looking strangely” at young neighbours.
“Joel is possessed by the devil ... and I didn’t suspect anything,” she said.
