Charlie Beckerman did an excellent breakdown of this scene:
To do a close read, Michelle's face is a chorus of conflicting emotions. The arched left eyebrow that is pure, unadulterated WTF, the narrowed eyes that are struggling to make sense of the whole thing (by which I'm going to go ahead and say means everything that's happened since the Republican Convention), the subtle smile that is 100 per cent "what is this? I can't even," and, capping it all off, the direct, can-I-get-a-witness direct eye contact with the camera. "Is somebody else seeing this?" her eyes seem to say. "Please, tell me I'm not the only one seeing this."
People on Twitter were quick to chime in:
A few pressing questions remain.
1) Why didn't those guys in the hats do anything to prevent this painful moment?
2) What is in the box? The internet is DYING to know. A pewter frame with an eviction notice in it?
We are all Brad Pitt's character in Se7en:
There are plenty of sound theories doing the rounds on Twitter:
A few people have noted that Tiffany & Co have a flagship store next to the Trump Tower in Manhatten, so they literally picked up the gift from the Trumps' corner store.
Presumably Melania and Donald dropped into the White House pre-inauguration ceremony so that Michelle could hand over the keys and take them through the house's little quirks (ie the dicky key that you have to jiggle for the back flywire screen and the best cycle to use on the dishwasher).
Well, Michelle shouldn't feel bad about this whole gift fiasco. In a way, she's giving the Trumps the gift of the White House, which is a very nice pile of bricks indeed.
So that probably Trumps a Tiffany box any day.