He then contacted the Jury Central Summoning Bureau directly, saying: "I told the Jury Central Summoning Bureau that I thought I would be inappropriate seeing as I happened to be the judge and knew all the papers," he told The Times.
But even after he contacted the bureau, they rejected his appeal for exemption and said to take the matter up with the resident judge for Winchester and Salisbury.
Cutler responded, again, this time cutting straight to the point.
"I am the resident judge."
Cutler phoned them up and explained the situation, with the bureau finally seeing common sense and exempting the judge from jury duty.
Cutler said he always wanted to be on a jury, mainly to see if he liked the judge and gain an understanding of what it's like on the other side of the courtroom.
In the UK, ignoring jury summons can earn a fine of up to £1000.