Traditional Russian wooden nesting dolls, Matryoshka dolls, depicting US President Donald Trump and his wife Melania (left) and Russian President Vladimir Putin, (right), are displayed for sale at a gift shop on the touristic Arbat St in Moscow. Photo / AFP
Traditional Russian wooden nesting dolls, Matryoshka dolls, depicting US President Donald Trump and his wife Melania (left) and Russian President Vladimir Putin, (right), are displayed for sale at a gift shop on the touristic Arbat St in Moscow. Photo / AFP
Donald Trump claims a close relationship with Vladimir Putin, citing past interactions and shared challenges.
Experts suggest Trump overestimates this relationship, viewing Putin as an aspirational figure.
Despite friendly rhetoric, Trump’s actions included sanctions on Russia and military support for Ukraine.
“Let me tell you, Putin went through a hell of a lot with me,” Trump said on February 28 in the unprecedented and very public Oval Office clash.
“He went through a phony witch hunt,” Trump added, referring to an investigation during his first term into whether his 2016 election campaign colluded with Moscow.
Even though that allegation was repeatedly denied by the Kremlin, the Republican President seems now to be saying the incident forged a sense of solidarity between the leaders.
The day before, in talks with British Prime Minister Keir Starmer, Trump said he believed Putin would “keep his word,” adding: “I spoke to him, I’ve known him for a long time now.”
For Sasha de Vogel, the associate director of the Authoritarian Politics Lab at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Trump “sees Putin as almost an aspirational figure”.
“He sees Putin as a strong man, a leader who is the decider in the situations that he is involved in, who has made Russia a much stronger country on the global stage during his time in office – and Trump wants to have that same kind of position.”
Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy (left) and US President Donald Trump (right) and meet in the Oval Office of the White House. Photo / AFP
The researcher, however, believes that Trump “overestimates their relationship”.
“Putin is not a businessman who Trump can earn the trust of. Putin is a highly strategic, extremely experienced politician,” she said, adding that the former KGB agent is “not operating on these same kinds of terms of personal like and dislike”.
‘Great-power politics’
Other experts note a certain ideological convergence between the longtime Russian leader and the new US administration.
Putin hopes to “return to a model of great-power politics, where the United States and Russia can negotiate as equals and agree on spheres of influence,” Natia Seskuria, an associate fellow at the Royal United Services Institute, wrote in Foreign Policy magazine.
According to Seskuria, the Russian leader believes that all territory of the former Soviet Union is his “rightful sphere of influence,” while Trump has a similar “expansionist mindset” that extends to Greenland, Canada and even the Panama Canal.
After a long telephone conversation on February 12 with Putin, Trump said the Russian President wanted “peace” in Ukraine, adding: “I think he would tell me if he didn’t.”
Ukrainians and Polish supporters hold banners during a "We Stand With Zelenskyy And Europe" demonstration in Krakow, Poland on March 1. Photo / AFP
On other occasions, he has called Putin “a very smart guy” and “a very cunning person,” all the while refusing to call him a dictator – a word he has used to describe Zelenskyy.
Trump “wants to be liked/respected by Putin, not understanding that ... Trump’s fawning over him will be greeted by scorn in the Kremlin,” said Timothy Ash, a Russia specialist at the London-based think tank Chatham House.
‘Driven by emotion and by personal vengeance’
De Vogel, however, said calling Trump a puppet of Putin, as some Democrats have done, is too reductive.
“He changes his mind quite quickly. He’s very driven by emotion and by personal vengeance and things like this,” she told AFP.
“And for that reason, he’s also erratic as a partner to Russia.”
During Trump’s first term in the White House (2017-2021), the United States was not as favourable to Moscow as the Kremlin had hoped it would be.
Trump agreed to sell Javelin anti-tank missiles to Kyiv, and his administration imposed a series of sanctions on Russia.
The US leader sprang a surprise again on Friday, writing on his Truth Social platform: “Based on the fact that Russia is absolutely ‘pounding’ Ukraine on the battlefield right now, I am strongly considering large-scale banking sanctions, sanctions, and tariffs on Russia.”
Shortly afterward, in an exchange with reporters, Trump’s tone became much more conciliatory, as he said it was “easier” to deal with Russia than with Ukraine.
“I’ve always had a good relationship with Putin. And you know, he wants to end the war,” he said.
“I think he’s going to be more generous than he has to be, and that’s pretty good. That means a lot of good things.”
