In her book Yvonne Ridley says Western intelligence agencies conspired to have her killed as a spy by the Taleban to drum up public support for the war.
The claim is based on a file of doctored personal papers, which she says her Taleban captors received within days of capturing her.
It
has been treated sceptically by rival British media, but a panel of BBC reviewers agreed it certainly added drama to a compelling but sloppily written book.
Their comments, on last week's BBC Newsnight arts programme, included the following:
Mark Lawson (host): She wrote it in six days. Does it show?
Tom Paulin (poet): It does. She's got no sense of place. All the Afghans are "flame-haired" or have "emerald eyes".
Lawson: There's a saying in journalism that you need to have a story or a style. She does have an amazing story.
Craig Brown (satirist): I think she has an amazing style. It was one of the great comic masterpieces. If I was making up a joke hack, I'd just copy that book out. She's a great one for cliches - "the mind boggles" and "Afghanistan is a country of contrasts". I thought that was great! She says it took her six days, but [detective writer Georges] Simenon used to write his books in a weekend. What did she do for the remaining four days?
Lawson: The sexual politics is interesting. You do have this interesting paradox about a female reporter from the West going into a place where women can't work. Does she bring any of that out?
Miranda Sawyer (journalist): Yes, she does on occasions. But she obviously has a strong personality and sometimes that overwhelms everything. You often think that whether she was a man or a woman, she would do the same - she's quite bolshie
Lawson: She is far braver than all of us. She went there.
Brown: Of course, but we're not reviewing her case for a Duke of Edinburgh award - we're reviewing her book and it's a terrible, terrible book.
Story archives:
War against terrorism
Bioterrorism
Terror in America - the Sept 11 attacks
Links: War against terrorism
Timeline: Major events since the Sept 11 attacks
