"I feel like I'm in a horrible
Black Mirror
episode," his sister, Tiara Cunningham, told the
New York Times
, referencing the dystopian sci-fi television show. "I'm kind of lost without him, to be quite honest."
She told the paper she speaks with her brother often, but their conversation on February 12 worried her. "He sounded not like himself," she said. He did not reply to a text message she sent later, and their mother, Tia-Juana Cunningham, did not reach him either.
She and Cunningham's father, Terrell Cunningham, drove all night from their home in Waldorf, Maryland, to Atlanta, about 1000km away, arriving on Valentine's Day. What they discovered in their son's home raised more questions. Left behind were Cunningham's unattended dog, Mr Bojangles, and his wallet, cellphone and driver's license. His car was in the garage, the Times reported.
Terrell Cunningham also had concerns about recent interactions with his son, whom he described as focused on a host of professional and personal issues.
"The tone and the numerous exchanges gave us reason to be concerned about Tim," he said. "And I don't know if it's an instinct you have because it's your child, but it was not a normal conversation, and I was not comfortable."
The family did not immediately respond to a Washington Post request for comment.
The Atlanta Police Department said on Sunday it was still unable to find Cunningham after learning on February 16 about his disappearance and that it was depending on public awareness to help draw leads. Foul play is not suspected at this time, police spokesman Donald T. Hannah said.
The Centres for Disease Control described Cunningham as a "highly respected member of our CDC family", ABC News reported. CDC officials did not reply to a request for comment.
In his 40 Under 40 profile last year, Cunningham said he was "using the skills I have to improve and help the lives of others", referring to his work at the CDC.
The publication said he was continuing on his family's path into medical care; his father was an Air Force nurse for 30 years, and his mother worked for the state health department as a programme manager.
Leonte Benton, a friend who met Cunningham in a professional development group, said Cunningham "consistently made an impact on the local community and throughout the world".
The Cunningham family, meanwhile, continues their own dogged search as they sort out the bewildering disappearance.
"We just hope he will just come home safely. None of this makes sense. He wouldn't just evaporate like this and leave his dog alone and have our mother wondering and worrying like this. He wouldn't," Cunningham's brother, Anterio, told Fox 5 in Atlanta.