"There was probably a dozen-and-a-half men with shovels and bare hand digging, and I think they moved - with no exaggeration - seven tonnes of hard packed snow in about 10 minutes' time," Greenwich-Cambridge Police Chief George Bell told Albany, New York, ABC-affiliate WTEN.
The unconscious boy was found first, but paramedics couldn't resuscitate him at the scene, according to the New York Daily News. He was taken to Saratoga Hospital, but it was too late. He was pronounced dead at 10pm.
The other boy was recovering at home.
Earlier this week, a snowstorm that swept into the northeast dumped a foot of snow in parts of the Great Lakes and upper Midwest and left half a foot across New York and northern New England, according to the Associated Press.
Greenwich got snow on Monday and Tuesday, according to The Weather Channel.
The boy's death was reminiscent of the death of 56-year-old David Perrotto on a snowy January weekend in eastern Pennsylvania.
Perrotto was trying to dig out his car - or possibly taking a break from the exertion or the cold - when a snowplow came by, burying the running car and blocking the exhaust pipe, police told Philadelphia NBA-affiliate WCAU.
Another person digging out a vehicle found the running car with an unresponsive Perrotto inside.