Price: We paid $832 for two nights.
Noise: There was low-level air-conditioning plant noise, which wasn't a problem.
What's in the neighbourhood: It's 10 minutes to wharf, and right outside is Key West's Main St with loads of shops and eateries, including a good cafe four blocks away and (unfortunately) a Starbucks underneath. There's a supermarket across the road.
Fellow guests: It was hard to tell where foreign visitors might have been from, as they were quiet.
We just heard Americans.
Facilities: A small swimming pool with spa and gym and an on-site restaurant.
Wi-Fi: Fast and secured although it can occasionally drop out for short periods due to the mains power dropping (the island's power comes from 200km of overhead, overwater lines from the mainland) until the hotel's generator kicks in and the Wi-Fi reboots.
Online: duvalcollection.com
Perfect for: Exploring Key West, taking tours of the town, and eating out.
Would I stay again? Definitely — it's what I wanted from a Key West hotel.