"We? It's not 'we', mate, I'm from New Zealand, but your men aren't doing too great right now."
We were quickly joined by four other octogenarians who, like all octogenarians do, had all the answers to fixing the national cricket team.
Brad Haddin had to go because he was "bloody useless" (the Aussie keeper went on score the second most runs in the series), Michael Clarke shouldn't have been the skipper (he led the side to a 5-0 series win) and Mitchell Johnson was their only decent bowler (he proved to be their best but was well supported) - a par and two bogeys for those suggestions.
But that is the beauty of 19th holes. You can talk with as much as accuracy as your three-iron and it doesn't matter. Unlike many bars around the world that are full of people who have a cellphone within finger's reach, 19th holes are made up of a generation oblivious to Twitter and Snapchat. Instead, they talk to each other and laugh in unison every two minutes. It's a wonderful thing.
But momentarily the laughter stopped as the English took another Australian wicket.
"Well, we might as well start supporting New Zealand," the first man said, winking at me.
His friends didn't get the joke and were clearly miffed by the notion of changing allegiances.
Two other visitors to the club spotted the TV and were set to join me in the Members' Lounge when it dawned on them that it was, as the name suggests, for members only. Something that I obviously hadn't realised.
I quickly finished my beer, waited till the end of the over and quietly left 1939.
CHECKLIST
Getting there: Qantas flies daily from Auckland to Melbourne.
Getting around: Hire a car from Avis at Melbourne Tullamarine Airport and drive the roughly 80 minutes to Bellarine Peninsula.
The writer travelled as a guest of Tourism Victoria.