Some viewers took to Twitter to express their bewilderment.
While explaining McEnroe's behavior has never been easy, his slightly off centre appearance was probably due to jetlag, having only flown into Melbourne that same morning.
In a chat with Channel Nine anchor Tony Jones before the night session, McEnroe talked about the long flight saying he was "very appreciative" of the opportunity to cover the event.
"When you fly in it's a hell of a lot easier to be a commentator than a player … commentating you just need a couple of hours. I'm raring to go."
Other than McEnroe's flailing arms, fans also questioned why Aussie Open favourite and four-time grand slam chapion Jim Courier wasn't the one conducting the interview.
"Kind of strange questions. I miss Jim...is he doing any on-courts interviews this year?" one fan asked on social media.
"Bring back Jim Courier!" wrote another.
Defending champion Federer faces Britain's Dan Evans in the next round.