Surfing experts and event organisers were also unable to say definitively whether the man nicknamed "G-Mac" had clinched another world best, amid reports the wave could have been as high as 100ft, but praised his bravery for tackling the waves.
The 2012 Association of Surfing Professional (ASP) World Tour champion Joel Parkinson was quoted as saying by surfertoday.com: "If this is real it's off the charts."
Both McNamara and Mamala were able to reach the waves in the Atlantic Ocean swell off the rocky coast of the fishing village, some 130km north of Lisbon, due to practice known as a "tow-in".
They were towed by a jet-ski towards the face of the wave, allowing them to catch the biggest rather than only using the strength of their own arms, as in traditional surfing. Rescue crews were on hand in case of any mishap.
Guinness World Records told AFP in emailed comments it was working with big wave surfing experts Billabong XXL to verify officially the exact size of the wave McNamara rode on Monday.
"Once the evidence has been reviewed and the height of the wave confirmed by Billabong XXL, then Guinness World Records will be able to confirm whether Garrett McNamara has broken his current record," it added.
- AFP