But here they are now, hosting another final in Wellington and with the odds stacked heavily in their favour. The Lions are good, but they are coming from Africa and there is a weight of statistics that says the away team hardly ever win a final and never do when they have travelled from Africa.
The Lions are good, but the weather forecast isn't and it's an acquired art playing in the worst Wellington can deliver - one the Hurricanes have perfected. Forget 2015 being their best chance, this Saturday is the ticket they can't, surely, fail to collect.
And they have reached this point because, when no one really thought they could, they have regenerated their midfield. Willis Halohalo, Vince Aso, Matt Proctor and Ngani Luamape have emerged almost from nowhere. They have managed to find their feet in stunningly short time and, as the season progressed, their influence has increased to the point where the Hurricanes midfield is not noticeably any less effective than it was last year with Nonu and Smith.
Halohalo, in particular, has been able to pick up a lot of the grunt work Nonu was always happy to do and drive the Hurricanes over the gainline in the last two months. The 320 running metres he's made in 590 minutes of football compares more than favourably with the 502m Nonu racked up last year in 1037 minutes.
His preferred midfield partner has become Proctor, who has put a steady hand on the tiller and a firm shoulder behind his tackling. Proctor has been rock-solid, the same sort of calming presence as the man he has replaced in the No 13 jersey, and even Hurricanes tragics will have been surprised at that.
How good this partnership could become isn't important. What matters is that they have been able to deliver what the Hurricanes needed this year and help them become, arguably, a better team.