The Lions were fortunate that Ruan Combrinck kept his cool and toasted his 50th Super Rugby cap to land a match-winning 55m bomb to snatch a 23-21 quarter-final victory over the Sharks.
Plumtree's old team very nearly returned the favour from the week before when the Hurricanes' defeat of the Crusaders saw the Sharks not having to travel to Christchurch.
But though the Lions struggled to get all their parts moving in the right direction, they still had some individual standouts, who will need to be subdued even if the match conditions of a 2.30pm kickoff will favour the expansive Hurricanes.
To the fore was stand-in skipper, loose forward Jaco Kriel, who made more metres (92) than any other player in the quarter-finals, beat eight defenders, and made 13 tackles.
Kriel was aided by fellow loose forward and Blitzbokke Sevens star Kwagga Smith at the breakdown and fullback Andries Coetzee. Threequarters Lionel Mapoe and Courtnall Skosan possess pace and portent finishing ability.
Plumtree did all but confirm that Dane Coles would start for his 100th Super Rugby game after returning, to good effect, from the bench in the 35-16 quarter-final victory over the Brumbies. Centre Vince Aso was also a chance to start after recovering from a groin niggle. That move would see a backline reshuffle, with Jordie Barrett heading back to fullback and wing Wes Goosen, who ran in a brace in Canberra, possibly drawing the short straw.
The match-day 23 will be named tomorrow evening (NZT).