Lachlan Boshier's tackle on Crotty was deemed to be dangerous. Photo / Getty Images
Lachlan Boshier's tackle on Crotty was deemed to be dangerous. Photo / Getty Images
The Crusaders' 45-23 win over the Chiefs has thrown the laws of the game back into the spotlight following a controversial call late in the game to award the Crusaders a penalty try.
Chiefs flanker Lachlan Boshier was yellow carded last night for taking out Crusaders and All Blacks midfielderRyan Crotty in what was deemed a dangerous tackle.
The Crusaders were leading 26-23 until the Boshier incident occurred in the 71st minute.
Crotty was attempting to score near the left hand corner flag when he was snapped up short of the line by Boshier.
Picking up the ball from the back of a ruck two metres from the line, Crotty went for a pick-and-go and dived low to the ground.
Boshier was the only Chiefs player on the scene and swung his arm around Crotty - making contact with his shoulder then his head.
Ryan Crotty is tackled by Lachlan Boshier. Photo / Getty Images
Crotty came up short of the try line and was pushed into touch.
After reviewing the footage with his TMO, referee Ben O'Keeffe decided that the correct decision was to yellow card Boshier and award the Crusaders a penalty try.
Reduced to 14 men, the Chiefs struggled to keep the attacking force of the Crusaders at bay, with George Bridge and Manasa Mataele scoring late tries.
Chiefs coach Colin Cooper - along with fans and spectators - believed that Boshier's tackle deserved no more than a penalty.
Swinging arm, force & contact to the head is a RED. You can't compare that yellow card to Antonio Kirikiri's yellow last night. Whether he ducked or not is irrelevant. #CRUvCHI
Everyone wants concussion out of the game. But at some stage common sense has to be used with decisions like that. He doesn’t hit him high, it only goes up because of the momentum and power used in the tackle. No wonder people struggle with rugby.
But, the TMO Aaron Paterson and on-field referee O'Keeffe, along with the Crusaders home crowd believed that he deserved to be carded and the penalty try awarded.
"It is foul play, it's a high tackle and he's in the process of scoring so I've got a penalty try and yellow card," O'Keeffe said after rewatching the footage.
Grant Nisbett and Justin Marshall - a former Crusader - were calling the game for Sky Television with both commentators shocked with the decision.
"This is again a tough one, what option did the defender have?" Marshall asked before the tackle was reviewed.
Ryan Crotty of the Crusaders receives medical help after the game. Photo / Getty Images
Highlanders lock Joe Wheeler described the decision as 'ridiculous'.
Ridiculous referee decision against the @ChiefsRugby the game of rugby really has turned into tiddlywinks #CRUvCHI
In the Hurricanes season opener, Bulls prop Pierre Schoeman was handed a yellow card for a swinging arm making contact with Vince Aso's head on the ground.
To get the day's top sports stories in your inbox, sign up to our newsletter here
