John Kirwan. Photo / Sarah Ivey
Opinion
When the global search for a new Blues head coach began, impressive names such as Nick Mallett, Martin Johnson and Eddie Jones were bandied about. Now that the final selection process involving a shortlist of candidates is under way, the reality is more mundane.
It appears the man charged with
resuscitating the Super 15 franchise after this season's wretched performance will be either John Kirwan, Kieran Crowley or Pat Lam, the incumbent.
It is surprising that Lam is even in the mix after a four-year stint that has registered 26 wins, 32 defeats and a draw. The lengthy nature of his term makes untenable the idea that he, like All Black coach Graham Henry after the failed 2007 World Cup campaign, should be allowed to learn from his mistakes. For the same reason, claims that injuries and player contracting difficulties are valid excuses for his record hold no water. Nor should Lam be part of the new coach's team. Given the state of the Blues, the new appointee must be allowed to start with a clean slate.
Crowley had a long stint in provincial rugby with Taranaki before being shown the door, and has subsequently coached Canada with moderate success.
Kirwan's coaching career rests on lengthy spells with Italy and Japan, again with solid results. But he presents the more persuasive, if not utterly convincing, case. His exploits as a player for Auckland and the All Blacks make him a local hero, and he would come with strong ideas.
