However, his solid performance in his first test at fullback, particularly his safety under the high ball, in last Saturday's 23-19 win over Argentina could see Barnes stay at No15.
Beale, dropped twice as starting fullback in the past month, has played his best rugby at five-eighths this year when he lined up as playmaker midway through the Super rugby season for the Melbourne Rebels. His combination with new Wallabies halfback and Rebels No9 Nick Phipps is also another argument for the 23-year-old to start his first test in the halves.
Former Wallabies centre Tim Horan believes Deans should move Barnes back to No10 where he performed with distinction in the 3-0 series whitewash of Wales and played beside inside centre Pat McCabe.
Deans named a 28-man touring squad on Wednesday for matches against the Springboks and Argentina (October 6) but only 25 flew out as lock Rob Simmons and backs Ben Tapuai and Mike Harris are allowed to play in tomorrow's Queensland club grand final.
None have been ruled out of the 22 to play the Springboks but Harris looms as the most likely to take a bench spot at Loftus Versfeld following news of Cooper's need for more knee surgery. Injured trio Stephen Moore, Sitaleki Timani and Dom Shipperley were all cleared to travel while NSW prop Paddy Ryan and Force winger Nick Cummins were the only uncapped players in the squad.
- AAP