He's nailing about 90 per cent of his tackles and has kicked 75 per cent of his goals - which is higher than Aaron Cruden, Colin Slade or Beauden Barrett - but there's not been anything impressive.
A mid-season resume would describe Carter's work as routine and nowhere near the levels we remember or he wants.
Injuries then a sabbatical cut his All Black input to 17 tests out of the 42 they have played since the last World Cup. In some, like the test against Scotland late last year, his production was very modest.
He'd squeaked on to the tour, ahead of Slade, after recovering from nerve damage to his lower leg but scarcely made an impression. That uninspiring work has continued.
No matter what position he plays, you'd expect someone with Carter's pedigree to have emerged from his cobwebs by now.
The Crusaders need him and a number of others to front up this weekend. The All Black selectors want to see that as well.
Carter's 1455 test points are a world record and his average 14.4 points a game are the sort of security blanket which is a bonus in high-pressure matches.
Teams need to lean on all that sort of know-how in the sudden-death stages of World Cups but Carter needs to show he still has that full range of tricks and is not withering under the heat of expectation.