Italy, known for their work at the set-piece in the collisions, were innovative and creative with the ball, and against a lesser centre than Smith they may have greatly prospered in that critical wide channel that is so hard to defend.
"We knew they were going to play and I was impressed with the variety of their attacking play," said Smith. "They were as good as any team I have played this year. There was no predictability about them - you never knew where they were going and they obviously got go-forward ball that helped.
"Their 9 and 10s read the game really well and whether they went round the fringes or looked for width they seemed to have a really good game sense. So there was a lot of work on defence for us."
The value of Smith is his ability to conduct real-time game analysis, to be aware of how the test is trending as it unfolds. That's what sets him apart - the bit his chosen understudy Ben Smith wasn't able to do so well against Scotland the previous week.
It's an unfair comparison as Smith senior has had 64 caps to learn his craft and understand the ebb and flow of test football. That experience is priceless and came to the fore in Rome as Smith preached patience.
The game was stuck for periods - the All Blacks unable to make passes stick or get gain-line ascendancy, but all the time Smith was urging those around him to stay calm.
"That's what happens when teams put you under pressure: you have to [not show frustration] and be patient. We talked about that during the week, we still did that at times, but ultimately after 65 minutes because we'd kept playing at pace we were able to score a few tries that probably inflated the scoreline beyond what was fair."
A nasty-looking bruise and cut under Smith's eye was a sign of the physicality of the contest and a sharp reminder that he's taken a pounding in his career.
A career that may go on hold next year - a temporary respite to give him a chance to maintain his place as arguably the world's best centre.
Southern comfort
The weekend's test results:
Samoa 26 Wales 19
New Zealand 42 Italy 10
Australia 20 England 14
South Africa 21 Scotland 10
France 39 Argentina 22