But it hasn't panned out that way. For whatever reason, Matulino hasn't totally harnessed his talents.
While Kiwis colleague Jesse Bromwich regarded among the best two or three props in the game, Matulino - though near the top of the tree - is on the next branch down.
He's still been very good, and is one of only three players to win the Warriors' player of the year award on multiple occasions (2012 and 2015), but there is more gold within. Still, the modest Matulino deserves recognition.
"For me it's just another game," said Matulino. "I get more of a buzz from other people's milestones, rather than my own. I was really lucky to play in Ruben [Wiki]and [Steve] Pricey's 300 games so that was a big buzz for me."
"But I didn't think I would get this far. Being a young fella playing first grade I was pretty happy with that and getting to play alongside guys I had seen on TV like Manu [Vatuvei] and Jerome Ropati. If I just played a couple of games with them I could tell my friends those are my teammates."
Matulino made his debut in round 14 of the 2008 season, against Cronulla at Toyota Park in Sydney.
Simon Mannering is the only survivor from that day, while Brent Tate, Logan Swann and Lance Hohaia were part of the roster, although Matulino's memories centre on the opposition.
"Greg Bird and Paul Gallen - the bash brothers as they were known back them," said Matulino. "I was definitely scared before that match and a bit nervous. I was glad to get through that game."
Matulino heads to Tiger town from next year, but is focusing his energies on a fine finale in Auckland, out to match his best year so far at the Warriors (2011).
"Our team on paper probably wasn't the best team," said Matulino of the team which made the grand final against Manly. "But everybody worked for each other. We knew what everyone was going to do, came through some tough patches and just stuck at it."