"Maybe we just all thought it was going to happen," said McFadden. "[It was] probably not unexpected that we had a little blip there but I didn't like the way it finished."
It's always dangerous to read too much into trials. In 2014 the Warriors smashed the Broncos 48-4 in Dunedin in their final trial, which fuelled all kinds of optimism. But the Auckland club then lost their first two matches of the regular season - while the Broncos won their first two - and coach Matt Elliott was gone by round five.
But after a full pre-season, and new assistant coach Justin Morgan putting a heightened focus on defence, some of the turnstile-type defending last Saturday was a surprise. Like we heard so many times last season, the issue was more about tenacity than technique.
"[Justin] has been working on consistency and positioning," said McFadden. "He has been working pretty hard with each individual but what we learnt on the weekend was that all those structures in place mean nothing unless you have the right attitude towards it. That's the big learning we got out of it."
But McFadden was confident that things could be turned around "very quickly", ahead of their first match next Saturday against the Tigers at Campbelltown, though conceded that the new look spine will take a bit of time to gel. That quartet is locked in, but some other positions remain up for debate, especially in the outside backs and the preferred forward rotation.
"We have a fair idea of what we are going to go with," said McFadden. "[Though] not too many good performances [last week] so a bit hard to read any form into it."