If we seek the latter at this stage with the view to being consistent semifinalists, then his next two seasons are crucial.
A year ago, the Warriors were being compared with the Parramatta Eels who sacked Stephen Kearney midway through 2012, appointed Brad Arthur as caretaker coach and then ended up with Ricky Stuart at the helm.
Their fortunes have since nosedived and the club props up the bottom of the NRL table.
For the Warriors, the sacking of Brian McClennan; the drawn-out process of appointing Elliott and the discarding of the popular Tony Iro drew similar criticism and ridicule from the Australian media, fans and the doomsayers in New Zealand.
But that's where comparisons between the two clubs end. If the Eels fans and club could fast forward 12 months and be in a position similar to where the Warriors are today, they'd think they'd died and gone to heaven.
The Warriors are in better shape now to become consistent performers in 2014. The stretch of six wins on the trot, after the embarrassing Penrith massacre, is a measure of what the team can do; consistency is their nemesis and making it a habit takes time.
Consistency comes through game-day intensity training. Repeating simple drills and skills. Doing this takes a different type of discipline to that of just going out and running around and being happy with only a few dropped balls in a session.
This team have nearly completed one year under Elliott and structure and improvement are expected beyond 2013.
It is has been a bumpy ride with the Warriors for much of the year, but fans would prefer to know what is coming at the next turn. This year has been more frustrating than enjoyable. Maybe the attitude of the younger players will improve to match that of some of the seniors. Earlier in the season I thought there was some immaturity which needed attention and signs have improved to indicate there has been change. Time will tell if this is maintained.