His former teammates and family are left to wonder what might have been. And Ropati has no doubt it would have been great.
"He would have played over 200 games, he'd still be here with the Warriors. I don't think we'd ever let him go. I wouldn't be surprised if he was captain to be honest because he wasn't afraid to speak. For a young guy he wasn't afraid to talk and bring about his opinions."
Ropati saw stylistic similarities with another superstar of the sport.
"Jason Taumalolo comes to mind. Strong, powerful, he'd play back row No 13, but he had good feet and was good at going forward."
Fai's prodigious ability to lift iron was what first caught the attention of his older, more illustrious clubmates. Ropati had heard about his gym work before he saw him play.
"I heard about how much he bench pressed. Yeah, that was amazing. He was benching something like 170kg, for a young guy like that it hurts - [I thought] I've got to see him, see what he's like."
Players lifting weights now have a permanent reminder of Warrior No138.
In the corner of the gym there is a mural of Fai.
Podcast can be listened to on iHeartRadio. For the full-length feature article click here.