"Are you serious? I beat five blokes,'' Gallen said.
The Sharks came again but it was appropriate that Cherry-Evans ended up with the ball to stop Cronulla's final charge, the absence of the injured Todd Carney hurting the underdogs as they struggled with their last-play options.
Still they were in the game until the last second against the wilting Sea Eagles, who face a monumental task backing up against the Rabbitohs in seven days.
Cherry-Evans' kicks led to first-half tries for Anthony Watmough and Kieran Foran, sandwiched around a Michael Gordon four-pointer on a rare foray down the opposition end for the Sharks.
Jorge Taufua took the Sea Eagles out to a comfortable 18-6 lead just after the restart, but there was plenty of controversy over the put-down with the hulking winger appearing to lose the ball as he crashed through four defenders.
The video referee deemed there was insufficient evidence to take away the try, but the Sharks were not down for long, Andrew Fifita showing once again there was plenty of finesse to the wrecking ball approach as he athletically put down a Jeff Robson grubber just before the dead-ball line.
Cherry-Evans crossed for what would prove the match-clincher on the hour, with Johnathan Wright's solo effort five minutes later getting the Sharks close but not close enough.
-AAP