Sure, it was questionable refereeing by Ben Cummins, who had an ordinary game, but the Kiwis shouldn't be putting themselves in those positions.
There was also a lack of mental focus. Letting Scotland back into the game so soon after David Fusitu'a scored his first try was one example, as were several fifth tackle defensive penalties which undid previous hard work. And then when leading with just over a minute to play, they weren't urgent enough to secure a short kickoff, from which Scotland grabbed possession and scored.
But there are some reasons for hope. If the Kiwis make the final next week, they will be outsiders against the Kangaroos, especially after the results in Newcastle, Perth and Coventry this year. Australia were dominant in all three matches.
But the Kiwis thrive on underdog status - they haven't handled the world No 1 ranking well - and have a tradition of peaking at the end of tournaments. They did that at the 2008 World Cup, when they reversed a 30-6 loss to the Kangaroos in the pool stage to an astounding 34-20 win in the final.
There was the same recipe in 2010. A comprehensive defeat in the group stages to Australia was followed by an-against-the-odds 16-12 win in the final.
That, however tenuous it might seem, is something to cling on to.