The lead tic-tacked numerous times as both teams used their expansive skills. Counties were rewarded with a try to Sikeli Nabou in the 75th minute which turned the match as Adam Bradey and Brendon O'Connor failed to pull him down.
Earlier two plays between the 53rd and 58th minutes looked crucial to the result when the holders pushed ahead 21-17.
No.8 Mark Atkins had one of Hawke's Bay's stronger games and was rewarded with a try minute when he slipped past Baden Kerr. Kerr was a strategic influence for the challengers at first-five and they would have been grateful for his presence after he recovered from a haematoma to his left leg. Just not at that moment. Atkins sprinted 20m to the line.
Five minutes later, Counties-Manukau captain Fritz Lee had the option to take a penalty goal to the right of the posts when Hawke's Bay led 21-17. He opted for the scrum and the subsequent pass from Augustine Pulu wasn't accurate enough pushing down the blindside. The challenge looked in doubt.
The opening half was relatively fluid, both teams getting their share of possession and utilising potent outside backs. Counties scored the first try through Sherwin Stowers down the left flank, after some sparkling footwork from Augustine Pulu. Gillies Kaka responded after flicking a ball inside on the 40m mark; he backed up and cantered across.
The goal kickers Kerr and Ihaia West cancelled each other out with the sort of accurate penalty shots that make teams think twice about infringing anywhere in their own half.
Hawke's Bay 24 (G.Kaka, M.Atkins tries, I.West con, 4 pen) Counties-Manukau 27 (S.Stowers, S Reidy, S.Nabou tries, B.Kerr 4 pen) Halftime: 16-14.