"It was plenty of weight, but he carried 73kg earlier on in the year so he should have been up to it."
The Cossack underwent a veterinary examination following the race, which came back clear.
"He pulled up fine. They vet checked him and he was good and he recovered really quick, so it was a bit of a mystery really," Nelson said.
The son of Mastercraftsman is currently under the watchful eye of expat Kiwi trainer and former top jumps jockey Craig Thornton and Nelson said he will rely on his feedback when making a decision on whether they press on to the Grand National Steeplechase (4500m) at Ballarat later this month.
"We will see how he is in the next few days and have a rethink," Nelson said.
"He is with Craig Thornton and Craig is very qualified to give us a sound report on him. We are considering the steeplechase in three weeks' time."
The Cossack has been a dominant force in the New Zealand jumping scene over the last few seasons, unplaced in just one of his 15 jumping starts.
He remains undefeated in steeplechase events, having won the Ken And Roger Browne Memorial Steeplechase (3900m) two starts back.