Coach Maggie Haney, left, watching Laurie Hernandez during a training session in April 2016. Haney has been suspended for eight years by USA Gymnastics. Photo / Charles Mostoller, The New York Times
Laurie Hernandez won medals at the 2016 Games. But she said her love of the sport was tainted under training with Maggie Haney, who is now suspended by the sport's American federation.
For the longest time, Laurie Hernandez, an Olympic champion gymnast, thought she was crazy for thinking that her coach had emotionally abused her.
When that coach screamed at her for the tiniest of mistakes or lapses in focus, calling her weak, lazy or messed up in the head, with an obscenity for emphasis, Hernandez rationalised that all top coaches pushed their young gymnasts that way. When she stood frozen and bawling at the gym, her heart racing as she struggled to breathe, scared to do anything that would elicit her coach's wrath, Hernandez — an adolescent at the time — assumed she just couldn't handle the pressure.
She considered it possible that many coaches publicly berated their gymnasts for gaining weight and developing the curves that come with puberty, and that they pushed athletes to train on dislocated knees and broken wrists. She had become convinced that was how Olympians were made.
When she complained about mistreatment, she recalled, her coach would tell her to stop taking things so personally. And then Hernandez would end up apologising for causing trouble.
"I thought I deserved all of it," Hernandez, 19, said in an interview with The New York Times on Thursday, the first time she has spoken publicly about the abuse she says ignited eating disorders and depression that she continues to battle.
"The toughest part about it was that there were no bruises or marks to show that it was real," she said. "It was all just so twisted that I thought it couldn't be real."
This week, Hernandez received a measure of validation that the mental anguish she experienced under her former coach, Maggie Haney, was, in fact, real. USA Gymnastics, after a weekslong hearing on accusations that Haney had verbally and emotionally abused athletes, suspended her from coaching for eight years.
A panel organised by the gymnastics federation evaluated evidence from at least five of Haney's athletes, including Hernandez and Riley McCusker, a strong candidate for the Tokyo Olympics next summer, and found that Haney had engaged in "severe aggressive behavior" toward gymnasts that included trying to control a minor by ridiculing her.
Haney, 42, did not respond to two requests for comment. Her lawyer, Russell Prince, said that Haney planned to appeal the ruling and that the hearing process was "fundamentally flawed in a multitude of ways."
The suspension was a significant step by USA Gymnastics to change the sport's overall culture, which many gymnasts criticized in the aftermath of the sexual abuse scandal involving the former national team doctor, Lawrence G. Nassar. He is now serving what amounts to a lifetime prison sentence for molesting more than 200 girls and women.
Emotional and verbal abuse is rampant in the sport, many gymnasts said then, with athletes so afraid of their coaches that they rarely speak out about any mistreatment.
Hernandez did not tell her mother details about Haney's conduct until 2016, weeks after she competed in the Rio Olympics, and she did so then only because her mother had overheard her in a FaceTime conversation with a former teammate about Haney's pulling that gymnast's hair.
The two teenagers were laughing about it, and Wanda Hernandez, a social worker, stopped them to say: "I'm sorry, but what are you saying? No one should be touching you or grabbing you."
After her daughter, then 16, told her everything, Wanda Hernandez immediately called Haney to terminate her services and sent a complaint to USA Gymnastics. She said she eventually had to demand that Haney stay away from Laurie because Haney kept making contact.
She said that she had also informed other families at Haney's gym and that she had reached out to the state's child protection agency to report Haney. A report couldn't be filed, Wanda Hernandez said, because the abuse had happened in a private gym, not in a public place like a school.
A year or two later, she spoke with Morinari Watanabe, the president of the international gymnastics federation, at a meet in Chicago and discussed the need to teach gymnasts that they should feel safe speaking up about abuse.
Still, it took USA Gymnastics four years to penalise Haney, and the national federation acknowledged in a statement on Friday that the "investigation and resolution process must be faster in the future."
The Hernandez family considered the outcome a move forward for the sport.
"I thought they were just going to try to sweep it under the rug," Laurie Hernandez said of USA Gymnastics. "But, wow, they did the right thing. I can't believe they actually did the right thing."
Hernandez, who is from Old Bridge Township, New Jersey, was 5 when she began training with MG Elite, Haney's team in central New Jersey. Hernandez remembers being bubbly and outgoing back then, but by the time she was a teenager she found herself crying some mornings before getting out of bed as she anticipated seeing Haney at the gym.
She said Haney sometimes screamed at her so loudly that people could hear it from the parking lot.
The gym was Haney's dominion. The team handbook says in underlined red ink: "Parents are NOT allowed to stay and watch practice," and "There are NO EXCEPTIONS!"
Hernandez recalls happy times with Haney, like team banquets and sleepovers at her house or trips to get ice cream, but at the gym Hernandez invariably felt stuck. She wanted to leave, she said, but couldn't speak up because she was just a child, unable to walk out or drive home. Feeling helpless, she would often cry, angering Haney even more.
Early on, Hernandez sought help from her mother, who contacted the coach. The next day, Haney showed up at the gym in a rage, telling Laurie Hernandez, "So, your mother called me." Then, Hernandez said, Haney punished the entire team by assigning extra conditioning work.
Eventually, Hernandez stopped telling her family about anything that happened at the gym, fending for herself instead. Puberty was an especially rough time.
"Maggie was saying to me, 'You already have a boxy body type, so we're going to have to keep an eye on your weight,' or shout, 'You're so busty!' for everyone to hear," said Hernandez, who started wearing two sports bras to flatten out her chest.
Struggling with her weight and pubescent body changes, Hernandez ended up binge-eating and purging. When she lost weight, Haney would praise her and Hernandez felt encouraged that the vomiting had worked.
"Any compliment was like holy water," Hernandez said. "It went from one day walking on eggshells with her to her saying the next day that 'we're in this together.' She really knew how to mess with your head."
Other teammates, she said, were similarly trying to cope. One, she said, was so scared of Haney that she would throw up before every practice.
The coach, she said, would also talk badly about Wanda Hernandez at the gym, saying things like "you should trust nobody because your parents are just going to kick you to the curb."
"Maggie would really trash-talk her, and it hurt a lot at first," Hernandez said. "But then I'd say, 'No, Mom, please don't complain to Maggie because you're only going to make her mad. She's doing the best she can.'"
Hernandez said she learned how to block out the abuse.
"As soon as Maggie raised her voice past a certain point, that space in my brain would pull the parachute and I couldn't hear her," she said. "As soon as practice was over, it was like my brain was a computer and I wiped out everything."
That's how Hernandez remembers making it through a practice after she fractured a growth plate in her wrist when she fell from the balance beam. She recalls Haney accusing her of being dramatic when she complained about the pain, much as the coach had reacted when Hernandez dislocated her knee at a national team training camp. The knee injury required surgery.
Hernandez competed at the Rio Olympics with a torn abdominal muscle, helping the United States claim the team gold medal and winning a silver medal on the balance beam.
After the Olympics, Hernandez parlayed her success into stardom outside the sport. She competed on Dancing With the Stars and won, in just one of her many television appearances. But despite the medals, the sponsorships and the two books she wrote, Hernandez regrets training with Haney.
"I'm grateful that I got to the Olympics, but at what cost?" she said. "I don't think it was worth it."
Hernandez said that she had struggled with "full-on major depression" and that she now receives treatment for it. She coped with her sadness by overeating and still has "a ginormous fear of doing something wrong, perfectionism to the extreme."
In 2018, Hernandez moved to California to start anew in her sport after taking time away to enjoy her Olympic success and heal emotionally.
Now at Gym-Max Gymnastics in Costa Mesa, California, Hernandez trains under Jenny Zhang and Howie Liang. It feels like heaven, she said.
It took a while to adjust, but when she makes a mistake now, she doesn't brace for a coach to yell at her. With the change, she knew that she really did love gymnastics.
"Whether I make it to Tokyo or not, I'm doing something I love on my own terms," Hernandez said, "and people treat me the way I want to be treated, and that makes me happy." She relaxes by singing or playing a guitar or ukulele, and she leans on her toy goldendoodle, Honey, a registered emotional support dog. Hernandez bought him as soon as she found out she would be testifying against Haney.
After testifying for 80 minutes at the USA Gymnastics hearing in February, Hernandez left feeling uneasy, wondering if she had "just thrown Maggie under the bus." She thought about apologising and asked herself, yet again, if she had deserved Haney's brutal treatment.
But several other gymnasts had testified about the abuse. She wasn't alone, and that comforted her.
At least for one moment, Hernandez felt that a weight had been lifted.
"It was really nice to finally tell people what happened," she said. "I did it for little Laurie and all the little kids out there."
Written by: Juliet Macur
Photographs by: Charles Mostoller
© 2020 THE NEW YORK TIMES
Mike Thorpe argues the numbers suggest that they are.