The turn of events left fans shocked and confused, with many taking to social media today to slam the competition as rigged.
"Anyone else think this is rigged and predetermined after the beige suddenly didn't win round one after leading all of the polling?" one fan questioned on Facebook.
"I demand a recount," another commented.
"This whole thing is rigged."
NZC responded to the accusations by saying the Grey Hoop received more than 60 per cent of votes across different platforms.
Voting for the second semifinal between the teal and the black kits closes tomorrow with the overall winner set to be decided on Friday.