Did Courtney Lawes come from an offside position to charge down TJ Perenara's kick?

That was the big question to come out of the All Blacks' 16-15 win over England at Twickenham on Sunday morning.

After the All Blacks began poorly but steadily improved and got the upper hand, the test effectively came down to a decision by referee Jerome Garces to review what appeared to be a try by England flanker Sam Underhill.

Read more:
All Blacks dodge bullet in controversial win over England at Twickenham
'Clearly onside' - UK media reeling after call that cost England win against All Blacks
All Blacks player ratings: Freakish Brodie Retallick leads from front
All Blacks: French ref Jerome Garces passed the buck on controversial call
Eddie Jones refuses to blame officials, believes England on track to be world's best


The crucial intervention (before Garces' own) came from England's replacement loose forward Lawes, who charged down an attempted clearance by All Blacks halfback Perenara in the 75th minute. The ball ended up in Underhill's hands, and the 22-year-old did brilliantly to beat Beauden Barrett to the line.

Had the try been awarded, England would surely have hung on for a famous victory. It would have been only their eighth against the All Blacks.

The big question in Garces' mind was: Did Lawes come from an offside position?

For Lawes to advance on Perenara, he had to come from the "hindmost foot" of the ruck when Perenara touched the ball. In other words, as the ruck continued and somehow made progress towards England's line, Lawes had to retreat before advancing, and the replays showed that while the rest of his teammates did, he didn't.

It was a clear case of offside. After several replays by television match official Marius Jonker, of South Africa, the message was relayed to Frenchman Garces and the All Blacks enjoyed a massive reprieve.

England players celebrate Sam Underhill's possible try. Photo / Getty Images
England players celebrate Sam Underhill's possible try. Photo / Getty Images