Black Caps fans seem to be split on the issue, with many voicing their opinions on Radio Sport this morning.
"One test win against England trumps five pajama [ODI] wins, hands down," said one caller.
"It's plain and simple! If he's not 100% he sits out, opportunity knocks for someone else," argued another.
Others took to social media: "If he can play, he should play! There is 12 days to rest between for the first test."
Ultimately, the decision could come down to Taylor himself, as pointed out by one Radio Sport caller: "You could rest Taylor for the ODI but he could still injure it first day of the test and you'd be stuffed for five days. Just let him make the call."
Regardless of whether Taylor plays on Saturday, all Black Caps fans will be thankful for Taylor's monumental knock that kept the series alive in the first place.