Social media quickly went into overdrive, with Liz d'Arbon summing up the situation saying: "Perhaps for the locker room chit chat - not for the big microphone and TV."
Another told Thaiday online: "You're talking to kids as well."
However, the effect of the comments are a little diluted given the 30-year-old seems to have a preoccupation with making comparisons between football and the bedroom.
He made almost the exact same comparison in April after he was denied a try when he was held up over the line in Brisbane's round six win over St George Illawarra.
"It was like almost losing your virginity," he told Fittler after the match.
"That's what it was like. I was so close but I didn't get there."
Read more:
Match report: Queensland grind out game one win
As it happened: Queensland take game one in low scoring affair
Player ratings - Origin I
Sam Thaiday criticised for 'virginity' comment after Origin win
The unfortunate comments were in stark contrast to those of star No. 6 Johnathan Thurston, who used his post-match speech to make a shout-out to the troubled community of Aurukun.
It followed another night in which both men's side again broke records and hearts on NSW soil.
For while the Blues had won six of eight series openers here at Sydney Olympic Park, it was Queensland who bashed their way to a 6-4 win with Maroons skipper Cameron Smith becoming the most capped Origin player in the process.