"With its best performance of the year, Mexico took advantage of a docile New Zealand to destroy the dreams of the Oceania Champions," said Reforma newspaper. Sports daily Estado proclaimed: "Against a rival from the end of the world, Mexico rediscovered their punch in the cruellest of World Cup qualifiers."
The Mexicans, while hailing their side's performance, were unimpressed with the All Whites. One commentator felt the New Zealand side tried to erect a "modern day Great Wall of China" while another summed up the prevailing mood: "We were worried, mainly because of what we had seen in 2010," said a correspondent on ESPN Deportes. "But this team lacked strategy, strength, speed and skill."
Almost half of respondents to a newspaper poll felt the result reflected Mexican superiority, while 41 per cent thought the major factor was the weakness of New Zealand.
Another poll had 28 per cent attributing Mexico's dramatic return to form to the low level of the opposition, more than the new coach (25 per cent) or the prevalence of players from a single club (18 per cent).
However most experts recognised the huge impact of the loss of Winston Reid and another pointed out that "this team has players without clubs and also amateurs - how can they compete with professionals. The miracles of the past don't exist in modern football."
There was also high praise for goalkeeper Glen Moss, with one writer claiming his heroic performance "stopped it becoming an even more tragic day for the visitors" and his string of fine saves "prevented a massacre from becoming a holocaust".