The clip has swiftly done the rounds on social media, with fans likening it to some of the worst open goal misses.
“My mother would have scored that,” one X user wrote.
It was not all lost for Icardi and Galatasaray, however, as just five minutes later he again linked up with Akturkoglu to score what would eventually be the winning goal.
The penalty miss is not the first time Icardi has been in the news for the wrong reasons - the 30-year-old had a widely-publicised affair with former Sampdoria teammate Maxi López’s wife Wanda Nara and even had López’s kids tattooed on him.
The first time Icardi’s club at the time Internazionale played Lopez’s Sampdoria - the match was named the ‘Wanda Derby’ after Lopez refused to shake Icardi’s hand.
Argentinian legend Diego Maradona said at the time that Icardi was “dead to him” following the affair.
Icardi and Nara have since separated following a turbulent relationship.