It was an awful dismissal given the circumstances. Important minds in New Zealand Cricket frowned hard, and that was that. Redmond's card was marked.
But he was a strong performer for Otago in last season's Plunket Shield, topping the aggregates with 941 runs at 55, and could easily have got the spot which went to the other 34-year-old opener, Peter Fulton.
He kicked off this season with 154 and 39 against Wellington, then 56 and 22 against Canterbury and hit 67 for the makeshift West Indies selection at Lincoln this week.
He's done precisely what the selectors, Mike Hesson and Bruce Edgar would have wanted, make runs.
So this time they have given him a chance, five years on, and deserve credit for that.
Whether he makes the XI is another story, with Kane Williamson's rapid powers of recovery from a fractured thumb raising eyebrows.
Still, it's nice to see runs being rewarded. And if Williamson doesn't make it, and Redmond carries on in the same vein, it's what selectors tend to call a pleasant problem come the rest of the series.
The New Zealand squad for the first test: Brendon McCullum (c), Hamish Rutherford, Peter Fulton, Kane Williamson, Aaron Redmond, Ross Taylor, Corey Anderson, BJ Watling, Doug Bracewell, Tim Southee, Ish Sodhi, Neil Wagner, Trent Boult.