But in their rush to be clever and start counting the likes, the social sleuths missed the mark.
Anyone with a basic understanding of newspaper deadlines would have understood how the switch occurred.
A closer inspection of the front page pointer revealed the photographs used were from the red carpet, earlier in the night before Warner and Perry had been named the best male and female cricketers in the country.
Why were those images used instead of the photographs of the two together? Deadlines.
The newspaper was given the result of both medal counts in advance so it could get its pages to the printer in time.
At that time, the artist only had a select group of images taken as the players entered Crown Palladium in Melbourne — and surprise surprise Warner walked in with his wife, Candice, while Perry arrived solo.
When deciding how to arrange the two separate photographs, the artist would have placed Perry in front of Warner because he could etch cleanly around her shoulders. Warner's left side was pressed up against his wife, so he was placed behind Perry.
And the decision on how tall to make him? It likely wasn't a decision at all.
Maybe the artist just felt like it looked better with the person on the left being slightly elevated. Just like the day before when 160cm Scarlett Johansson was made to look taller than 170cm Al Pacino (and no one got upset).
So sorry angry Twitter mob. There's no conspiracy here, just more fake news.