He'd played just six first-class games and the smart alec end of the Australian cricket media group assumed the selectors had meant to select the tubby opening batsman, and soon to be captain, Mark Taylor, and got their Taylors muddled.
"Peter who?" roared the headlines.
Peter Taylor didn't take the slight well but responded with six for 78 in England's first innings, valuable second innings runs and eight wickets in the match to be named man of the match in a 55-run win.
Craig got cracking with two wickets in an over, opener Kieran Powell and Kirk Edwards, and added bowlers Kemar Roach and Sulieman Benn to his bag later as the home side were dismissed for 262, a first innings deficit of 246.
He extracted turn and bounce from the sluggish pitch to share the honours with Tim Southee, whose four for 19 from 16.2 overs was an outstanding return.
Aucklander Craig, who shifted to Otago looking for an upswing in fortunes, doubtless occasionally thinks back four years when a bout of chronic fatigue syndrome laid him low for 11 months.
How his lot has changed. It's wise not to read too much into a first up test performance. But certainly it was encouraging and, given his back story, immensely satisfying for Craig.