"He was such an obvious weak link that took the pressure off whenever he came into the attack that Williamson limited him in the number of overs and then Sydney, which at the moment looks like it's going to be a spinning deck, Australia have just added an extra spinner to the squad, it's a big deficiency too have," Whateley said.
Australian cricket great Mark Waugh went even harder on Santner, pointing him out as the reason why the tourists won't win the test.
"He's a one-day bowler, not a test match bowler. If you're an orthodox bowler the one thing you've got to have is accuracy, yet he doesn't have that.
"He doesn't spin the ball a lot so you've got to have accuracy and he doesn't have that. He bowls short balls, too many easy scoring balls. I think it's a real big issue and the reason why they can't win this test.
"You've got to have a decent spinner in Australia or at least a spinner who can get wickets. At the moment he isn't doing that and he's not keeping it tight so I don't know what they'll do in Sydney, they'll maybe have to bring in a leg-spinner because I can't see Santner playing."