The turnaround was described as "unfathomable" by college basketball writer Jeff Eisinberg, who noted the 11-point deficit Nevada erased in less than 60 seconds was the second biggest final-minute comeback in college basketball history.
Texas A&M holds the record after fighting back from 12 points against Northern Iowa in last year's NCAA Tournament.
However, Nevada's was even less likely, considering they stormed back from 25 points in the second half and from five points in overtime, with Jordan Caroline finishing with a career-high 45 points.
Midway through the second half the Lobos led 74-49 and were still up 87-68 with 4:27 left before Nevada started hitting three pointers.
Marcus Marshall added 26 points, with 12 of those coming on four 3-pointers in the final minute of the second half - the final two banking in and the last one tying it with seven seconds left.
Nevada had seven three pointers in the final 1:49.
New Mexico recently recruited Kiwi point guard Quinn Clinton, who will be hoping that his side can avoid anything similar when he makes his collegiate debut next season.
- With news.com and AP