"It really is an institution," said Canstar Blue's Emma Quantrill, "it's just something we love to do and for four out of five New Zealanders, a BBQ is an essential home appliance".
Consumer Magazine has also rated the American Weber barbecues four stars out of five in a recent survey, saying they cook well, are easy to use and easy to clean.
Other brands to do well in the Consumer survey include Everdure, Char-Boil, Matador and Beefeater.
In a Consumer gas versus charcoal BBQ taste test last November, Weber was praised for making "exceptional cooking systems" that cook things easily and evenly with its popular Q-series barbecues small enough to fit on an apartment balcony.
For Consumer technology writer Haydn Green, the Broil King Keg was the pick among the Weber and a basic four-burner with a smoker box on the grill for smoking meat or long, slowing cooking, but not good for simple barbecuing.
"The Weber may be 'boring' but it performs exceptionally well," Green said.
One of the judges, chef Aaron Wagstaff, said the judges did have a laugh over the official recipes online for things like hot cross buns.
Their advice? "Just use an oven."