"I just have to wonder about the management of the river in that area over many years," he said.
Councillor David Holmes, whose property borders the Ruamahanga River at Lees Pakaraka Rd, said degradation of the river there has dropped the river bed by a metre.
"We now have to cut a channel to get the water out to the paddocks."
Mr Holmes said contractors had taken "a hell of a lot of metal" out of the river over many years and river management now meant metal was moving further and further south.
He said it was acknowledged water races were very inefficient and that it is going to be interesting to discover how the Wairarapa as a whole deals with that problem.
Te Ore Ore was a very small scheme in comparison with others including Taratahi in the Carterton district and the Moroa Scheme in South Wairarapa.
During the public forum section of the council meeting Settlement Rd farmer Cameron Stuart told councillors he "sadly" had to support closure of the water race as future costs of trying to keep it would be prohibitive. He too spoke of the riverbed level dropping and had his "theories" as to the cause.
Ripping had meant "the metal has gone", Mr Stuart said.
He said he had attempted to build up the level using boulders to allow water to flow into the race but this had not been viable and 500m upstream machinery was working at taking metal out.