"I was scratching my head when I was talking to him, wondering when did she have an opportunity to let go a bottle in Cook Strait?"
Her daughter was amazed the message she wrote when she was 10 years old, which included a description of Masterton and a self-addressed envelope, had been found intact so many years later, and told her mother the bottle had been thrown overboard by the father of a Fernridge pupil who worked on an Inter-Island ferry.
What made it even stranger was how close Mr Gillam lived, Mrs Price said.
"He was quite amazed that he actually found this and that the address was just around the corner from us.
"I don't know what the odds would have been ... it's a strange set of coincidences."
It was unclear where the bottle had been on its 19-year journey, but it was possible it had come to shore years ago and had then been pushed back out to sea by recent bad weather, as it was quite clean and had no barnacles attached to it when it was found on the beach, Mrs Price said.
"I just thought it was very nice of him to get in touch with us and bring it around rather than just throwing it into the rubbish bin."