All Blacks supporter Brooke Price, aged 26, said women in the stadium were making jealous remarks about Robinson's role.
"He's the player all the girls are drooling over at the moment and for that to happen to him on the opening night of the Rugby World Cup was gold," Price, of Hamilton, said.
Social media sites including Twitter, Facebook and YouTube were flooded with marriage proposals, bids for the ripped shirt and bawdy statements.
"He just took his shirt off, he did he did ... he can't put it back on, too tight... OK, getting a bit hot in the office! Grrr Sonny Bill Williams," Christine Hewitson tweeted on the night.
Radio personality Dominic Harvey wasn't ashamed to admit he was impressed with the hulk-like body: "SBW shirt rips on his tattooed side? Too good to be true. And then a slow-mo of the rip. Even I'm aroused," he tweeted.
He told the Herald on Sunday that everyone at his house, including the men, were glued to the TV when the shirt came off. "I'm completely comfortable with my sexuality to admit he is a handsome fellah," Harvey said.