Friday, 01 December 2023
KaitaiaWhangareiDargavilleAucklandThamesTaurangaHamiltonWhakataneRotoruaTokoroaTe KuitiTaumarunuiTaupoGisborneNew PlymouthNapierHastingsDannevirkeWhanganuiPalmerston NorthLevinParaparaumuMastertonWellingtonMotuekaNelsonBlenheimWestportReeftonKaikouraGreymouthHokitikaChristchurchAshburtonTimaruWanakaOamaruQueenstownDunedinGoreInvercargill
NZ HeraldThe Northern AdvocateThe Northland AgeThe AucklanderWaikato HeraldBay Of Plenty TimesRotorua Daily PostHawke's Bay TodayWhanganui ChronicleThe Stratford PressManawatu GuardianKapiti NewsHorowhenua ChronicleTe Awamutu CourierVivaEat WellOneRoofDRIVEN Car GuideThe CountryPhoto SalesiHeart RadioRestaurant Hub
Voyager 2023 media awards
Subscribe

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.
Home / New Zealand / Politics

Report suggests no juries in rape trials

Nicholas Jones
By
Nicholas Jones
5 Aug, 2016 05:00 PM3 mins to read
Saveshare

Share this article

facebookcopy linktwitterlinkedinredditemail
Justice Minister Amy Adams is weighing a Law Commission report that could transform the legal process for both complainant and accused. Photo / Mark Mitchell

Justice Minister Amy Adams is weighing a Law Commission report that could transform the legal process for both complainant and accused. Photo / Mark Mitchell

Rape trials could be heard before a judge alone - not a jury - under radical proposals before the Government.

Justice Minister Amy Adams is weighing a Law Commission report that could transform the legal process for both complainant and accused.

The primary recommendation - likely to be implemented with broad support - is to try out a specialist sexual violence court, with expert judges and lawyers.

But other ideas are much more controversial, including scrapping juries in favour of another model.

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.

Outlining allegations in front of a jury could be traumatic, the commission noted, and such cases were more likely to result in a hung jury.

In 2014/15, 8 per cent of sexual violence cases before District Courts were retrials, compared with 0.8 per cent of all trials.

There were also "powerful cultural conceptions" that were "unique to sexual violence as a form of criminal offending". These could include moral beliefs about how a woman should behave, and misplaced ideas about how sexual violence occurs or the "correct" response.

The commission concludes there is a case for eventually putting sexual violence cases before something other than a jury - perhaps a judge alone or judge with two expert "lay assessors", as in Germany.

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.

The report went to Adams last December. She has said she is considering it.

This week a jury of four women and eight men could not reach a verdict in the trial of cricketer Scott Kuggeleijn for the alleged rape of a woman in Hamilton.

The case put the spotlight on consent and how sexual violence cases are treated by the courts, with women's rights advocates denouncing the defence strategy as part of a culture of victim-blaming.

Labour's spokeswoman on sexual and family violence, Poto Williams, said in many cases she believed a judge alone or other entity would be better than a jury. However, jury trials would still be needed in some situations, and how that was decided would be critical.

Related articles

New Zealand|Politics

Audrey Young: David Bain, Teina Pora and the compensation argument

02 Aug 07:53 AM
New Zealand

Editorial: Denying Bain compensation is hard justice

02 Aug 05:00 PM
New Zealand|Politics

David Bain: $1m payout but no apology

02 Aug 05:00 PM
New Zealand|Politics

Bain payout a test of Justice Minister

05 Aug 05:00 PM

Steve Bonnar, QC, convener of the Law Society's criminal law committee, said scrapping jury trials would be a significant erosion of a defendant's rights. It was an unfortunate reality that not all complainants were victims.

"Sometimes these are some of the more serious cases that people can be prosecuted for ... it would be an erosion of many centuries of legal process."

The Law Commission has also recommended providing an alternative process for certain lower-level cases, outside the criminal justice system.

Victims would initiate the process and seek redress such as an apology or payment and the perpetrator would not have a criminal record.

Sexual violence law reforms

Law Commission recommendations include

• A sexual violence court as a two-year pilot, with specialist judges and counsel.

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.

• Have District Court and High Court judges take training courses in order to sit on a sexual violence case.

• Consider an alternative to juries in such cases -- perhaps a specially trained judge alone or judge with two expert "lay assessors".

• Consider limiting the right to trial by jury in sexual violence cases.

• Enable victims to seek redress such as an apology, and which wouldn't lead to a conviction.

• Ensure cases start in a timely fashion.

Saveshare

Share this article

facebookcopy linktwitterlinkedinredditemail

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.

Latest from New Zealand

New Zealand

Angry Northlanders say incoming Govt has traded children's health for tax cash

01 Dec 03:00 AM
New Zealand

Cancer strikes South Canterbury preschool twice

01 Dec 02:47 AM
New Zealand

Hastings Boys’ headmaster to be farewelled at his school on Wednesday

01 Dec 02:41 AM
New Zealand|CrimeUpdated

'Foul play' suspected in Harley Shrimpton disappearance, man arrested

01 Dec 02:36 AM

Top toys of 2023 for kids & ‘kidults’

sponsored

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.

Latest from New Zealand

Angry Northlanders say incoming Govt has traded children's health for tax cash

Angry Northlanders say incoming Govt has traded children's health for tax cash

01 Dec 03:00 AM

Angry Northlanders say the changes will cost lives

Cancer strikes South Canterbury preschool twice

Cancer strikes South Canterbury preschool twice

01 Dec 02:47 AM
Hastings Boys’ headmaster to be farewelled at his school on Wednesday

Hastings Boys’ headmaster to be farewelled at his school on Wednesday

01 Dec 02:41 AM
'Foul play' suspected in Harley Shrimpton disappearance, man arrested

'Foul play' suspected in Harley Shrimpton disappearance, man arrested

01 Dec 02:36 AM
Toy trends for Christmas
sponsored

Toy trends for Christmas

About NZMEHelp & SupportContact UsSubscribe to NZ HeraldHouse Rules
Manage Your Print SubscriptionNZ Herald E-EditionAdvertise with NZMEBook Your AdPrivacy Policy
Terms of UseCompetition Terms & ConditionsSubscriptions Terms & Conditions
© Copyright 2023 NZME Publishing Limited
TOP