Robertson supporters Maryan Street and Kris Faafoi were demoted by four and three places respectively. Mr Cunliffe said some people had to drop to allow others to be promoted, but Ms Street was also given the tertiary education portfolio to help compensate for it. He said Mr Hipkins was moved down because it was important to have the Maori Affairs spokesperson on the front bench. Labour only has eight allocated front seats in Parliament, but Mr Cunliffe said Mr Hipkins remained on his technical front bench of 10.
Mr Twyford said he believed the promotion was because housing was one of the battlegrounds in the election, especially in the Auckland area where he was an MP.
Other MPs spoken to about the changes said they had been told not to comment on the reshuffle, which was prompted by the resignation of Shane Jones.
Mr Robertson picked up Mr Jones' most significant other portfolio of economic development. Andrew Little moved to 11th in the rankings, up from 17, and keeps his justice and labour portfolios.
Kelvin Davis will replace Mr Jones after he leaves on May 21 and has been ranked at 22, getting associate roles in regional development, education, police and corrections.
Winners
• Phil Twyford: picks up transport again and up five places to six on the front bench.
• Nanaia Mahuta: gets Maori Affairs and up one onto the front bench.
• Andrew Little: up six to 11th ranked.
• Trevor Mallard: up at least nine, from unranked to 15th.
• Grant Robertson: picks up Shane Jones' economic development portfolio.