Session ID: 2025-08-14:96b3b2a6c8f15959974fe591 Player Element ID: vjs_video_5665704772001
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
End of dialog window.
This is a modal window. This modal can be closed by pressing the Escape key or activating the close button.
Autoplay in
3
Disable Autoplay
Cancel Video
Dr. Liam Pomerleau from Otago University National Poisons Centre explains botulism. The family was heavily tested for botulism. Footage from Three / Newshub
A church holding funds raised for a family struck down by severe poisoning has only released part of the $100,000 donated.
The St Thomas Marthoma Church of New Zealand released $42,520 of $102,764 raised earlier this year for the Kochummen family after three members were hospitalised with suspected botulism poisoning.
Shibu Kochummen, 36, his 65-year-old mother Alekutty Daniel and his wife Subi Babu, 34, of Putaruru were struck down with vomiting, convulsions and paralysis in November last year after eating wild boar.
They spent weeks in intensive care in comas before recovering. Botulism was eventually ruled out after tests were negative and the cause is still unknown.
Their care was taxpayer-funded because Kochummen, a mechanic and Babu, a nurse, are New Zealand citizens but Daniel is not.
Unlock all articles by subscribing to this international offer
All-Access + BusinessDesk Weekly
Herald Premium, Viva Premium, The Listener & BusinessDesk
Before ACC approved cover for Daniel, a Givealittle fund was set up by the Hamilton Marthoma Church and almost $30,000 was raised.
Another $70,000 was donated to the church following a separate fundraising initiative by the parishes, and in January the $42,000 was released to enable the family to travel back to India where their two young children, aged 7 and 1, were being cared for by relatives.
Family spokesman and Hamilton Marthoma Church parish secretary Joji Varghese said he made repeated requests of the New Zealand church vicar for the remaining $60,224 to be released to the family.
Instead he says he was referred to one of the church bishops in India, Dr PT Joseph, Mar Thoma Metropolitan, who did not respond to his inquiries.
Subi Babu, Shibu Kochummen and his mother Alekutty Daniel with the couple's children before they were struck down with severe poisoning. Photo / Supplied
"From February onwards is when this whole thing started to reek of something is happening that shouldn't be happening."
Varghese said the Hamilton parish put their concerns in writing and threatened to go to police if the matter was not resolved.
He said although ACC covered Daniel's care, the couple could not work until recently and Babu had not returned to work full-time because of the effects of the illness.
Church trustee Cherian [Abu] Thomas told the Weekend Herald: "Recently, we got verbal approval from our bishop and we are expecting his written approval."
Thomas said Mathoma Church, a Christian faith based in south-west India, received the donations to support Daniel who was on a visitor's visa when she became ill.
"She did not have any travel insurance and hence she needed a huge sum for her treatment."
But in an email from Bishop Joseph, dated January 27 and seen by the Weekend Herald, the bishop gave instruction to release only enough to cover the airfares to India.
"The remaining amount can be put in congregation account as separate fund," he wrote.
"The remaining amount can be carried over to new year account... No money be released with out [sic] my permission at any time. Tell them this is my directives given to you."
The bishop and the New Zealand vicar, president and Reverend VT Kurian did not respond to Weekend Herald emails.
When contacted by phone Kurian said he couldn't talk because he was travelling to Hamilton for a monthly service, and to put questions in an email.
Church accountant Philip Kuruvilla said the church's processes were robust and transparent and he was unsure why there had been a delay in releasing the funds.
Shibu Kochummen said he did not want to comment on the situation.
A Charities Commission spokesman said it would only be considered misuse or misrepresentation of the money if it was used for other purposes, which did not appear to be the case.
In those cases criminal charges such as theft or fraud can apply.
"It's this really grey area, third party fundraisers."
The Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment said it did not have scope over such situations and police referred questions to the Charities Commission.
