"We had a couple pies left over and they were thrown into the ocean. One of my fellow divers said, imagine if a shark ate one of the pies.
"I picked up my camera and started recording, sure enough a Great White shark jumped up and grabbed the pie."
A seagull also had a lucky escape during the incident. Photo / Rose Gullery
Gullery couldn't be contacted tonight, but footage of the incident uploaded online showed a seagull on the surface of the water scarpering just before the shark lunges for the pie.
A man on the boat then asks "did they just eat a pie?", referring to the shark, as others laugh.
According to the Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History, breaching - which is what the shark did when it came up for the discarded pie - is relatively rare because the shark has to use so much energy to propel itself.
"Great white sharks breach in order to catch fast-moving prey like seals. Swimming fast at the surface, sharks can reach 40 miles per hour (64km/h) and fly 10 feet (3m) into the air."