The airline had two incidents in 2009. In July that year, passengers were horrified when an engine exploded and a propeller tore into the plane in flight. In September, a passenger plane heading for Auckland crashed shortly after take-off.
Hayley Kerr said the plane had started to take off yesterday on the Pauanui airstrip, which runs the length of the exclusive development on the east of the peninsula, but it failed to leave the ground.
Eyewitnesses said the engines roared as the female pilot fought to keep the plane under control.
Kerr said it ploughed through a wooden barrier at the end of the strip and headed for a skate bowl. "Everyone at the skate bowl was screaming just before it stopped."
The plane stopped in a garden about a metre short of a public walkway before the skate-bowl.
Bonnie Parker was in a large crowd at the weigh-in of the Big Catch Fishing Tournament when the plane careered through the barrier.
She said the person running the weigh-in watched his crowd turn and run outside to see what had happened.
Great Barrier Airlines owner Gerrard Rea did not return calls.