"But it is a little bit disturbing that it's happening in a tourist town, where people are vulnerable," he said.
However, the 19-year-old, who has spent seven months in Paihia on a working holiday, said robberies happened everywhere. "Any time I come out of a bar, there's police around. I don't think there's any more they can do."
Mitchel Flynn, also from Vancouver, said travellers ran the same risk wherever they went.
"If it happened every day, then I'd start to get a bit concerned."
The 26-year-old heard about the second crime when a friend in Auckland texted him to make sure he wasn't the Canadian who had been robbed. He already took care to keep his property locked away but would be a "a bit more cautious" in future.
Richard Wales, 31, from Newcastle in England, had heard about the "car jacking" of his fellow countrymen.
"It is pretty shocking, especially when it's in a quiet little town like this. You expect it in the big cities."
However, it had not changed his liking for Paihia.